Repair or replace

Repair or Replace Your Fridge, Washer or Dryer?

For fridges, washers and dryers, we weigh the appliance's age and the repair it needs against the 50% rule. Call us before you buy new.

Old refrigerator standing next to a new stainless refrigerator in a garage

Appliance Repair or Replacement: Where to Start

Two rules settle most repair or replace calls on a refrigerator, washer, dryer or dishwasher. The first is Consumer Reports' long-standing rule of thumb: don't spend more than 50% of the price of a new appliance repairing an old one. The second is age. Past about 10 years, a big repair usually stops paying off.

National cost guides set a stricter test for a fridge: fix it if it's less than 10 years old, still has warranty coverage, and the repair comes in under half the cost of a new unit. Few fridges tick every box, so treat that as the best case. A seven-year-old fridge out of warranty with a $300 evaporator fan repair is still an easy yes.

Both rules need a real repair price, and that comes from the visit. The tech tests the part, names it and writes up the price, and you hold that figure against half of the replacement you'd actually buy, not the cheapest one on the showroom floor. A counter-depth French door costs more to replace than a basic top-freezer, so its repair ceiling sits higher too.

The 50% Rule for Appliance Repair

National prices for a new unit, cut in half. A repair price under the line for the model you'd buy usually means fix it. Over the line, a new one starts to make sense.

RepairTypical rangeNotes
Refrigerator (new $675 to $2,500)$340 to $1,250Most fan, defrost and gasket repairs sit under it; a compressor often doesn't
Washer (new $700 to $1,300)$350 to $650A drain pump fits easily; a $350 to $900 spider arm can cross it
Dryer (new $800 to $1,200)$400 to $600Thermal fuses, heating elements and belts all land below it

National prices, not Houston quotes. Use the price of the model you would really buy.

Calculator and an open appliance manual on a kitchen counter

Refrigerator Repairs Worth Making

NAHB's life expectancy study, built on 2005 industry estimates, gives a standard refrigerator about 13 years. Here's how the common failures stack up against that, at national installed prices.

Door gasket, $100 to $300
Worth it at almost any age. A torn seal lets humid Houston air into the cabinet and keeps the compressor running longer, and the gasket is one of the cheapest parts on the fridge.
Evaporator fan motor, $250 to $400
Worth it on anything short of the end of its life. A dead fan is a common reason the fresh-food side warms up while the freezer stays cold.
Defrost heater, $120 to $400
Usually worth fixing. Frost that keeps building on the back wall of the freezer points here, or to the sensor or control that runs the heater, and the tech tests which one failed.
Control board, $400 to $750
Depends on age. On a four-year-old fridge, fix it. On an 11-year-old basic model, the board alone can reach half the price of a new one. On the visit: Ask the tech whether the board is still made, since parts for older models can be backordered or discontinued.
Refrigerant leak, $400 to $1,100
The warranty decides a lot here. LG and Samsung both cover sealed-system parts on their refrigerators well past the first year, so a leak on a young unit may be covered. Give us the purchase date along with the symptom.
Compressor, $700 to $1,250
Replace in most cases past about 10 years. The exceptions are a compressor still under an extended parts warranty, or a built-in fridge where the new one has to fit the same cabinet opening. The refrigerator and freezer repair page goes through the other parts behind a warm fridge.

Garage Refrigerator: Repair or Replace

Summer here means roughly 111 days a year at 90 °F or hotter, going by the Bush Intercontinental normals, and a garage fridge sits through every one of them. A kitchen fridge isn't built for that heat, so the compressor runs longer to keep up. Garage-ready models are rated for a much wider range of room temperatures.

So when an old kitchen fridge that got moved to the garage needs a big repair, a garage-ready model is worth pricing as the replacement. Tell us on the call that the fridge lives in the garage.

Is a 10-Year-Old Washer Worth Repairing?

Sometimes, if the failure is small and the drum is sound. Ten years is NAHB's estimate for a washer's life, and national cost guides count a washer under 7 years old as one sign a repair is worthwhile (a fix under half the price of a new one, or warranty coverage, are the others). Past that age, the part decides it.

A drain pump at $150 to $350, a door lock or lid switch at $100 to $300, or a belt at $100 to $200 can buy more years for well under the $350 to $650 line. Worn bearings are a different story. Bearings alone run about $100 to $250, but a job that takes the outer tub too costs $600 to $800 or more, and a cracked spider arm $350 to $900. A grinding or roaring spin usually points to bearings, and the tech confirms which repair it is before you see a price.

Front-loaders typically cost more to fix than top-loaders, so a front-loader reaches the line sooner. The washer repair page goes through the other parts and symptoms.

Older top-load washer beside a utility sink in a garage

Appliance Repair Under a Parts Warranty

Most brands cover the whole appliance for one year, but several cover the costliest parts much longer. Parts-only coverage still leaves the labor, and the date on the receipt decides which term your repair falls under.

LG refrigerators
Parts and labor on the whole fridge for the first year. LG's current US terms keep the sealed system and compressor covered, parts and labor, through year 5, then the linear or inverter compressor part only through year 10. Older editions differ.
Samsung refrigerators
5 years on the sealed system, with longer coverage on the digital inverter compressor.
Samsung washers
Digital Inverter Motor covered for 10 years on many models. The model number and the purchase date decide whether yours qualifies.
LG front-load washers
Drum motor covered 10 years, parts only.
Maytag
Ten years of limited parts coverage on major appliances built after 2017, with parts and labor in the first year.
Whirlpool refrigerators
Sealed refrigeration parts covered in years 2 to 5 on some models. More on the Whirlpool appliance repair page.

Dryer, Dishwasher and Range Repair Decisions

Dryers mostly stay under the line. NAHB gives a dryer 13 years, and the usual no-heat parts are cheap: a thermal fuse runs $75 to $150 installed and a heating element $150 to $350. Have the vent looked at on the same visit, since lint choking the vent is what usually blows the fuse. The dryer repair page covers the rest.

Dishwashers sit near the bottom of the NAHB table at about 9 years, level with microwaves, so a dishwasher reaches the age line sooner than most. A $100 to $400 drain pump on a young machine is still worth doing. A $200 to $600 control board on a nine-year-old one usually isn't. More on the dishwasher repair page.

Gas ranges last longest, about 15 years by NAHB's count, and national cost guides only point to replacing an oven once it's 10 to 20 years old. A $150 to $325 igniter is nearly always worth it. The oven and range repair page lists the other common parts.

Will a New Model Cut Your Electric Costs?

Some, but rarely enough to decide it alone, so use the savings to settle a close call.

Refrigerators

  • ENERGY STAR certified models are about 9 percent more efficient than the federal minimum
  • Swapping an old fridge for a certified one saves about $150 over a 12-year life, per ENERGY STAR
  • That rarely justifies replacing a fridge that needs a $300 repair

Washers

  • Certified washers use about 20 percent less energy and 30 percent less water than regular models
  • ENERGY STAR estimates about $530 in energy savings over the washer's life
  • A full-size certified washer uses 14 gallons a load, against 20 for a standard machine

Repair or Replace Questions

Is a 15-year-old refrigerator worth fixing?

Only for a small repair. Fifteen years is past NAHB's 13-year estimate, so a gasket ($100 to $300) or a defrost heater ($120 to $400) can still make sense, but sealed-system work rarely does. The written price from the visit gives you the real number to weigh.

Should I replace the compressor or buy a new fridge?

Check the age and the warranty first. A compressor runs $700 to $1,250 installed nationally. On a fridge under about 8 years old with the compressor part still covered, the repair can make sense. On an out-of-warranty fridge past 10, that money usually goes further on a new one.

Can the tech tell me whether it's worth fixing?

Yes, and that's most of what the diagnosis is for. The tech names the failed part and puts a price on it in writing, and you hold that number against half the cost of a new appliance before deciding.

Can an old refrigerator go out with Houston heavy trash?

Only with a tag. The City of Houston takes refrigerators and freezers in heavy trash only with a certified technician's tag showing the refrigerant has been removed. Stoves, washers, dryers and water heaters go out without one. Collection is every other month for eligible addresses.

Does a second breakdown mean it's time to replace?

Not by itself, but it's a strong signal on an older machine. Add the two repairs together and run the half-price test on the total. A washer that needed a pump last year and needs a board now may have cost more than half of a new one.

Call Before You Replace It

The visit names the failed part and puts a written price on it, the number the half-price test needs. You only pay for work you agreed to.

Call (713) 379-8612